Jill Morningstar is the author of the novel Eva Schmidt. She serves on the Lung Cancer Research Foundation Board of Trustees, and she lives in Takoma Park, Maryland.
Q: What inspired you to write Eva Schmidt, and how did you create your character Eva?
A: Eva Schmidt was inspired by the extraordinary historical figure Bertha Pappenheim, a leader of the German Jewish women’s rights movement in the first third of the 20th century. She was a brilliant, accomplished passionate woman with a highly complicated past.
Because I wanted to write fiction, and I preferred to write about the Weimar and early Nazi periods, I decided to create Eva Schmidt, an illegitimate orphan raised by Bertha Pappenheim.
My goal for Eva was to mirror Bertha’s complexity. She is an intelligent, brave and imperfect protagonist. When we meet her in 1933, she works as a dive bar fortune teller in Berlin. Because of the shames of her past and the rise of Nazism, her Jewishness becomes her most closely guarded secret.
I began thinking the novel would focus on Eva’s relationship with Thad Cartwright, an American intelligence officer, but when I discovered the true story of Magda Goebbels, wife of Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels, I knew she would be someone to whom Eva would have to become attached.
Only through navigating the gray spaces between Eva and Bertha, Thad and Magda, can Eva finally confront her past and save herself.
Q: How did you research the novel, and did you learn anything that especially surprised you?
A: The good news about writing about the Nazi era is the tremendous amount of literature available. I researched mainly by reading nonfiction.
The books that were most important to the process were: The Enigma of Anna O, by Melinda Given Guttmann, Magda Goebbels by Anja Klabunde, The “Jewish Threat,” by Joseph W. Bendersky, and The Jewish Response to German Culture, edited by Jehuda Reinharz and Walter Schatzberg.
To better understand the culture of the time, I read novels and commentaries from Hans Fallada, Walter Benjamin, Lion Feuchtwanger, Joseph Roth and Siegfried Kracauer, among others.
I was most surprised to learn the bizarre history and hypocrisy of Magda Goebbels. Her past relationships with Jewish people and her experience as a refugee shocked me given what we know about her actions after becoming a Nazi and marrying Joseph Goebbels.
She joined Eva Schmidt after I had started writing because she was too interesting to leave out. As drafts were done and redone, she emerged as one of the most significant characters.
Q: The Kirkus Review of the book called it a “thrilling tale of shame and redemption.” What do you think of that description?
A: I think the description was wonderful. Despite Eva’s many gifts, Eva’s life was limited in many ways by her feelings of shame. Eva’s first words in the novel are: “My story was told in three words, a quick whisper falling from a maid’s yellowed lips. Bastard. A Jew.” These three words haunt Eva throughout the novel.
Frau Pappenheim demands Bildung! Sittlichkeit – Education! Respectability! from her orphans. It was a mold that left Eva “misshapen and bruised.” Eva excels at everything her “spiritual mother” asks of her. She says that Frau Pappenheim’s praise “could hold me for hours. It made me better than I was. But better than I was wasn’t enough. My truth cropped up like crab grass, ugly nubs she couldn’t polish over. I was an illegitimate orphan living among Ostjuden girls.”
The Eastern girls were victims of the pogroms. As Eva says, “Their hundreds of words telling of dead mothers and shattered glass made our teachers cry . . . At night, when . . .I heard the Eastern girl’s tears, I wanted their reason to cry. My sadness came only from my shame, so I never cried.”
When Eva moves to Berlin, her shame as a Jew grows. Frau Pappenheim admonishes her, “Jews carry an unenviable burden of proof, and you, as an orphan, all the more so.” After burning her identity papers and becoming enmeshed among the Nazi elite, Eva fears her past is inescapable.
She sees an Ostjuden hawker by the side of the road and thinks, “How much happier I would have been living outside the ever-looming shadows of these wailing, waiting people. I didn’t know if I could escape them. I didn’t know if I wanted to. Despite my lies, my past would not go away. It was asymptotic. No matter how much I slashed it, halved it and beat it down, it would never reach zero.”
Eva’s push and pull with her past takes her through a treacherous maze. She faces seemingly impossible choices and dead ends. Her answers aren’t right or wrong, heroic or evil. She makes mistakes, but over time, she does her best when there is no best to be had.
I hope readers will offer Eva the redemption she seeks. I hope they will see the strength in the love she learns to give to the people in her small universe. I hope they return that love even when, as Frau Pappenheim says, “you need to look through dark to see it.”
Q: Especially at a time of increasing antisemitism, what do you hope readers take away from the novel?
A: The things from the early Nazi era that glaringly echo for me are the lies. Hate is born of lies, and today’s antisemitism is no exception. Eva says of the new Hitler regime, “Justice was gone, truth was erased. Basic language had new meaning. Words like ‘instinct, fanatic and death were exalted, while ‘truth,’ ‘reason,’ and ‘intellect’ were weak, venal, the odious domain of a subhuman race.”
While we are not where Germany was in 1933, we are living through a painful, ugly time. I have never felt this level of antisemitism before, and it is coming from all directions. People ascribe to us the lies we thought would not come back, at least here. I don’t know what to do about it, but somehow we have to return to the truth.
I hope people take with them Eva’s reaction to a letter she receives from Frau Pappenheim. Bertha Pappenheim actually wrote these words in response to the growing anti-semitism in Germany prior to the Nazi takeover. In the novel, she shares them with Eva:
“Thunderous rage fills me! I will preserve it, it shall burn in me—as long as what rightfully arouses it exists. I will not become lenient. I hope that I may retain the strength to cry out in passionate anger, again and again, to condemn every injustice!”
Eva reacts:
“Her pride was a blunt object, beating me over the head. I read the letter again and again, searching for a place into which I could fit. I scrounged for a hint of something that was meant for me, not for the person I should have been, not for the person I’d left so far behind. There was nothing. I took out a sheet of paper and scrawled her a note. I miss you. I’m doing my best. It’s not close to enough.”
I am grateful for every person who cries out in passionate anger and condemns every injustice, especially as lies and the hatred they cause grow more powerful and more vicious. But we also can find inspiration and truth in those who find their own way to try, even when it is not close to enough.
Q: What are you working on now?
A: I am writing a novel about love, religion and murder on Key West in the 1920s.
--Interview with Deborah Kalb. Jill Morningstar will be participating in the Temple Sinai (D.C.) Authors Roundtable on March 15, 2026.












