Janet Kintner is the author of the new memoir A Judge's Tale: A Trailblazer Fights for Her Place on the Bench. She lives in Victoria, Canada, and San Diego, California.
Q: Why did you decide to write this memoir?
A: I had a lot of available time during Covid, and I was thinking about all the changes I saw in my 50-year career as a lawyer and judge. I saw how much more difficult it was for women to get justice when we were not in positions of power in the legal system, including me when I was the victim of a terrifying crime.
Those were hard lessons, and I didn’t want them to get lost. I thought if I didn’t write about these stories, they could very well be forgotten and we could go back to where women were excluded from being lawyers and judges, which I am convinced would hurt all women, including victims of crime, witnesses, and parties.
Q: The author Wendy B. Correa said of the book, “This courageous memoir recounts Kintner’s fight for fairness in a system stacked against her and her relentless belief that justice belongs to everyone.” What do you think of that description?
A: I love it. Wendy gets me. When I became a lawyer, almost everybody said they would not hire a woman lawyer--government agencies and private law firms. I didn’t give up and I finally got a job at Legal Aid of San Diego, representing low-income people.
My pay was modest compared to most lawyers’ incomes. But I got a chance to prove myself and I loved almost all my clients. I specialized in consumer fraud and my clients were victims of fraud. They were often single parents working hard to support a family with very little money. I talked about some of my favorite clients and cases in my book.
Although I was new and young, I went up against some of the biggest law firms in town. I felt justice belonged to everyone, not just the wealthy.
Some of the judges were rude to us female lawyers. I had a judge who mostly ignored me and was solicitous of the male lawyers in a big law firm on the other side. The judge refused to follow the law, but I could prove my case, and I didn’t give up.
Q: What impact did it have on you to write the book, and what do you hope readers take away from it?
A: Writing the book took me back in time. I had to relive the unpleasant things, like when I was a victim of crime, and justice was elusive. That was painful.
But there were good things about writing it too. I invited to my home some people who were key characters in my book—and in my life, like the investigators who helped me prepare my cases. I talked to others on the phone.
We talked about the old days, and they helped refresh my memory about some details. It was heartwarming to renew our friendships and catch up on each other’s lives. Sadly, some have passed away since our visits, so I’m especially glad we got together. I feel it’s important to preserve their legacies in my memoir.
I hope readers will be impacted by my descriptions of what it was like before women had positions of power in the legal system. That was a difficult time for women, especially for female victims of crime but also for all women. It stayed that way until more women were lawyers and judges.
I trust people will read my book and see the importance of having women in leadership positions and work to keep them there. I also hope readers will be inspired to find a way to help others in need and work to make the world a better place.
Q: What do you see looking ahead for the justice system in the United States?
A: I really don’t know. I thought we were progressing well toward equality for women and all people, which I thought was good. I also hoped we would have high-quality judges, who would be independent, competent, fearless, strong, incorruptible, nonpolitical, fair, and who would follow the rule of law and their oath to uphold the Constitution.
But there are some people who don’t want that, so the future of our justice system depends on who is in power. I think we all need to get involved, vote, and make sure good people are elected who will give us a quality justice system, because judges are elected or appointed by elected officials.
Q: What are you working on now?
A: I am working on writing a humorous fiction book.
Q: Anything else we should know?
A: Yes, I am working on passing on kindness. We all need to do that. I feel bad when friends and family members say they get depressed and worry about what is happening to our world. We all need to be kind to each other and remember we have more in common than what divides us.
--Interview with Deborah Kalb
















.jpg)
