Q:
How did you come up with the idea for your new book, and how did you research it?
A:
My first personal encounter with the phenomenon that I describe as “the cult of
death” happened when I entered a huge retail store to buy a tutu for my
daughter, and I was stunned by a new fashion line for newborns and toddlers
featuring skulls, crossed bones, and the Grim Reaper.
Dumbfounded,
I asked myself – has there been any other time in Western history when
millions of mothers wanted to see their kids dressed as skeletons
and covered with signs of death? We are surrounded
by this fad in our everyday – big retailers routinely sell skull and skeleton
patterned beddings, furniture, etc.
What's more, we are no longer surprised to be greeted by the Grim Reaper in pharmacies, let alone pubs and haunted houses all year around, or to have death studies included in high school curricula.
So, the question that captivated me was: what does this fascination with death
say about our popular culture and is this a unique cultural phenomenon?
Anthropological
studies made me realize that the fascination with death has created new
industries such as dark tourism, for example, and transformed funerals — this
most conservative of rituals — on both sides of the Atlantic to the point that
anthropologists speak about a revolution of burials.
How
can we explain why, apart from all other extravaganza, people chose to wear
jewelry made from the ashes of their relatives, not to mention so-called green
funerals, cryonization, promession etc.?
It
has soon become clear to me that anthropology or sociology cannot fully explain
the reasons behind these changes, and that other sources are needed to understand
them.
Obviously,
the fascination with death, and especially with very violent death is
remarkable in contemporary movies and fiction. It occurred to me that The
Vampire Diaries, Twilight saga, True Blood, the Harry Potter series and the apocalyptic genre such as Rise of the Planet of the Apes may explain the
nature of that cultural change.
All
these narratives have several features in common: they deny the exceptional
value of human life by showcasing how idealized monsters kill undistinguished
humans or reduce people to food.
We
should not underestimate the novelty of this image: in the entire history of
Western culture, people have never been represented in arts as legitimate snacks
for other species.
Q:
At what point did this new "celebration of death" become common, and
what do you see as the factors accounting for the change?
A:
The cult of death is a recent movement that has emerged at the end of the 1970s
– mid 1980s, and reached its full expansion in the late 1990s.
The
aesthetic cause crucial to its formation was the
Gothic Aesthetic.
This
powerful trend emerged, in the 1980s and early 1990s, when two features
overlapped in fiction and movies: murderous monsters became first-person
narrators with whom the audience was expected
to identify, and their plots and set ups were designed to immerse the audience
into a nightmare trance.
Gothic
Aesthetic promoted the normalization and idealization of monsters and the
denigration of humanity in contemporary popular culture.
Two
philosophical ideas are at the intellectual origins of the cult of death: the
critique of humanism and the rejection of human exceptionalism.
In
the late 1960s-1970s, these ideas were best
expressed by the French Theory, the animal rights movement, transhumanism, and
posthumanism. By the 1990s, they penetrated the popular
culture and became fashionable cultural commodities.
I
consider the tragedies of the 20th century an important historical premise of
the cult of death. The experience of the totalitarian regimes and the crimes
against humanity brought about a deep disillusionment with human beings, their
culture and civilization.
It
compromised the Enlightenment belief in human nature and the human race as the
one uniquely moral species, and created favorable preconditions for a disappointment
in humanity on a large scale.
I
think it is important to specify that the rise of the cult of death in the past
thirty years cannot be explained away by the decline of religion, which dates
back to the 18th century.
Q:
One of the themes you examine is the popularity of Halloween in the United
States especially. How have celebrations of Halloween changed over the years?
A:
Let me begin by saying that,
in the 1960s, Halloween was considered by
anthropologists as a dying tradition. Today, as we all know, in the U.S. this festival is second only to Christmas in terms of spending on decorations. It flourishes
in Europe, Russia, South Africa,
and Hong Kong.
Why
has this remnant of death-centered Celtic agrarian ritual become one of the
largest American holidays in the third millennium?
The
popularity of Halloween in America
rose in the mid-1970s - early 1980s, when the urban legends
about poisoned “treats” given to children by strangers, and the abduction and
murder of young children as part of Halloween rituals created a nationwide
panic.
In
parallel with these urban legends, which were proven completely fake, John
Carpenter’s Halloween (1978) started a new trend of horror movies. The rise of
Halloween’s popularity is unequivocally related to the anti-humanist and
anti-modern origins of that festival.
The
Halloween costumes and decorations, which
have been growing more and more horrific every year, offer one more proof
that Halloween, which allegedly involved human sacrifice,
was re-invented to promote a denial of the exceptional value of human life as a
fashionable commodity.
Q:
You also look at the phenomenon of Harry Potter. How do J.K. Rowling's books
fit into your thesis?
A:
One of my chapters is focused entirely on the seven books of the Harry Potter
series. I explain the enormous success of the Harry Potter franchise by these books' ability
to express new attitudes toward humans, humanity, and human life that originated
in Western culture in the late 1980s-early 1990s.
The
series was among the first to combine the
main features of Gothic Aesthetic: they feature a plot that imitates nightmares;
and wizards, nonhuman protagonists, who despise humankind, those repulsive
Muggles, as an inferior race.
Most
importantly, Harry Potter – a wizard disguised as a bespectacled boy -- amalgamated the features of the latest, most prominent, and most marketable character types that
had just entered the pleasure market in the 1990s: maniac, vampire, and serial killer.
The
Harry Potter franchise offered a new commodity -- a violent death of the main protagonist – as a
groundbreaking entertainment for children and adults alike. It also suggested
new attitudes to death to its audience.
Q:
What are you working on now?
A:
The fascination with violent death is intimately related to neo-medievalism,
which I consider a social and political expression of the new attitudes to
people spread by the cult of death.
Medieval
allusions are omnipresent in vampire sagas, the Harry Potter series, Game of
Thrones, etc. To my mind, they represent a specific form of distorted historical
memory. So, my new book, Neo-Medievalism: A
Social Project explores the meaning of medieval allusions in American and
Russian cultures and politics.
--Interview with Deborah Kalb